Substituting Indie-Yarn for Your Next Knitting Project

Substituting Indie-Yarn for Your Next Knitting Project

Hello, fellow yarn enthusiasts! Ready to embark on your next knitting adventure? Whether you're an experienced knitter or just getting started, one thing's for sure: choosing the perfect yarn for your project can feel like navigating a maze. But fear not! I'm here to guide you through the colorful world of yarn substitution with all the tips and tricks you need to ensure your knitting journey is smooth sailing.


Embrace the Swatch Life

First things first: gauge swatches are your best friend. Seriously, don't skip this step! Sure, it might seem tedious, but trust me, it's worth it.

I have yet to see a knitting pattern that didn't include a gauge guide. Grab the needles described in your pattern and the yarn you would like to substitute with. Your pattern will tell you how many stitches to cast-on and rows to knit. 

Once you've got your swatch, measure that bad boy to make sure your tension matches the pattern's gauge. If not, adjust your needle size either up or down until you get it just right. Think of it as a little test run before you dive into the main event.  

If your swatch matches the gauge - you're in business! It really is that simple. 

For best results on larger projects; try to stick to yarn from the same company. If you're really looking to mix things up and use a whole variety of indie-yarns; do multiple swatches of each yarn just to make sure your weigh/tension feels cohesive.

If I'm doing colorwork with yarn from different suppliers, I always do a swatch in the pattern - no surprises after spending hours knitting the yoke of your sweater!

Little tip: Sometimes, I've found some indie-yarn to be a little on the lighter size of the intended weight. When that's happened I've just knit with some mohair to bulk it up and get my gauge just right. 


Buy All the Yarn (Yes, Really)

Picture this: you're halfway through your project, cruising along like a knitting pro, when suddenly... disaster strikes. You run out of yarn, and the dye lot you need is nowhere to be found. Cue the frantic Google searches and desperate pleas on Ravelry.

Save yourself the stress and stock up on all the yarn you need upfront. Trust me, it's a game-changer. Plus, buying from the same dye lot ensures your colors stay consistent throughout your masterpiece. This is good advice for commercial yarn as well. Dye is fickle and no matter how dialed in the recipe - it comes out slightly different each time. 

Embrace the Indie Yarn Rainbow

Now, let's talk about the best part of indie yarn substitution: the endless possibilities! Say goodbye to cookie-cutter projects and hello to a world of unique colorways and textures.

Indie yarn dyers are like magicians, conjuring up hues you never knew you needed in your life. So don't be afraid to get creative and experiment with different yarn bases and color combinations. After all, knitting is all about expressing yourself, so why not let your yarn do the talking?


Don't Forget to Have Fun

Above all else, remember to enjoy the process. Knitting is so much more than just loops and stitches—it's a form of self-expression, a way to unwind (pun intended), and a creative outlet all rolled into one. So whether you're knitting a cozy sweater, a funky pair of socks, or a whimsical shawl, savor every stitch and embrace the joy of creating something beautiful with your own two hands.

So there you have it, folks: my guide to navigating the wild and wonderful world of indie yarn substitution. Armed with these tips, you're ready to take on any knitting pattern with confidence and flair. So go ahead, cast on those stitches and let your imagination run wild. The knitting world is your oyster, and the possibilities are endless!


I hope this article has been of help. For my UK stitchers - check out my collection of hand dyed yarns! All my yarn is cruelty-free and ethically sourced so you can knit with peace of mind.


Happy stitching!

Back to blog

Leave a comment